Get the Job, Part 1
Apr 6, 2010 12:00 PM, By Don Kreski
Thoughts on the science of writing winning proposals.
Loether, who was one of the authors of InfoComm's Audiovisual Best Practices, says he doesn't believe many consultants are offended by integrators who add qualifications or conditions to their bids. "A crucial factor for us is responsiveness; that is, the willingness to follow the directives and specifications in the RFP," he says. If it's apparent that you're working to better the project, bringing up a missing item is a good thing. "I need a team player," Loether adds. "I don't want to be in a superior/subordinate relationship. I think the contractor and design consultant should be working together to benefit the client."
While it's true that some consultants are less accommodating, overlooking a missing spec can have serious consequences. "In a way, you're betting your company on every big proposal," Schwarz says. For that reason, you want to keep management involved. "Everyone has, at minimum, an informal approval process, but to be successful, you need more discipline."
Dugas agrees. "We have a different model than most AV integrators," he says. At TSAV, one or more sales people and engineers work on every proposal, and at least one member of the management team reviews it before it goes out.
If the RFP does not already do so, Schwarz suggests breaking the project down not only by functional segments such as video, sound, or control, but by timing segments or milestones. These may include, for example, completion of engineering documents, delivery of equipment, and completion of programming. "Each of these milestones has to be something tangible that everyone can agree on, something you can test and ask the customer to sign off on," he says. Thinking in these terms can help you define the skills and resources needed to complete each phase of the project, help you keep the project on track once it has begun, and define points for progress billing.
"Another way to look at this is to create a schedule of values, where you define different segments of the job, the material and labor, and then bill when you reach certain percentages of completion," Dugas says. Though you see these mainly on larger projects following the American Institute of Architects (AIA)'s guidelines for process management, Dugas says this type of planning is a part of every large project at TSAV.
"[If you don't consider these kind of details,] you will find yourself asking your techs for heroic efforts during the installation," Schwarz says. "'We didn't know we were going to have to do this, but we'll just have to whip our techs to work from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m., because we can't get access during the day.'"
Dugas adds that, in many cases, "this is simple stuff, but we have to spell it out. We're the AV pros, after all. The client often is not."
When it comes to pricing the job, Schwarz suggests borrowing a method from government contractors called cost Basis of Estimate, or BOE. "The idea is to base your pricing on an historical database of past jobs," he says. "How long does it actually take your people to hang a projector?"
"Forensics is a big thing," Dugas says. "We routinely hold project closeout meetings and financial debriefings." Who the other bidders are is also important. One of the companies I used to work for kept very careful records of who won each bid and, as much as possible, calculated the markups they used.
"I suspect there's a definite correlation between the dealers who try to collect that type of information and those who are most profitable," Schwarz says.
In the end, what's most important to the person who will open your proposal? "Qualification is first," Loether says. "And next, it's responsiveness. Does the bidder show an understanding of the project and echo the priorities expressed in the RFP? Are any conditions or exceptions done in the spirit of wanting to help things, to benefit the client?" Price is very important, Loether says, but only after he's sure he has bidders who are qualified and responsive.
The science of preparing a bid, at least as we've defined it so far, has everything to do with responsiveness and price. The art, showing that you are well qualified to complete the project, is our topic for next month's "Marketing Mix."
Don Kreski is the president of Kreski Marketing Consultants, which offers marketing services to the AV industry. You can reach him at www.kreski.com/contact.html.
Continue to Get the Job, Part 2
Acceptable Use Policy blog comments powered by Disqus